
Mark Robinson of Iowa City writes about Chanse Creekmur, the gifted football and football player from Marshalltown who came up second-best to A. J. Derby of City High of Iowa City in the Little Hawks' 42-14 victory in the class 4-A championship game:
Hello, Ron:
"Chanse Creekmur wasn't given much time to do much of anything in Friday night's championship game. It appeared that his coaches wanted him to throw the ball deep even though Iowa City High continued to throw the kitchen sink at him on every play.
"A little dink and dunk might have helped the Bobcat team keep the City High offense off the field. It wasn't much of a game after the first quarter.
"I was more intrigued by a sideline interview with Creekmur's father at that point. As you know, Chanse accepted an offer from Iowa to play basketball, then he backed off and committed to Santa Clara.
"Apparently, he has backed out of that committment and now is looking to play quarterback for Iowa State. This seemed to be pretty well confirmed by daddyo during that sideline interview.
"After Friday night's game, Chanse...or his dad....might want to commit to something somewhere and stick with it. He may not have all that many opportunities left.
"Keep writing,"
Mark Robinson
Iowa City
[RON MALY'S COMMENTS: Mark, you're right about the Chanse Creekmur [pictured at the right] situation. I also think the dad seems far too involved with his son's collegiate athletic career. What I'm not sure of is which sport -- Division I football or Division I basketball -- the kid wants to pursue. That's the big question. If Iowa State is giving him a full-ride and he wants to play football, then that's where he should go. But if the kid thinks he's a Division I basketball player, he'd better have a great senior season and pursue that. Anyway, for the sake of those thousands of fans from Marshalltown, I was disappointed the Bobcats didn't play City High a little tougher. Marshalltown seemed to have things figured out early, but City High adjusted and wound up thrashing them the way they've been thrashing teams all season. In the final analysis, City High had some gifted athletes -- many more than Marshalltown had -- and the Little Hawks deserved to win. By the way, Derby -- like Creekmur -- is also an outstanding basketball player, but he has already committed to Iowa as a football player. As a Hawkeye, he wants to play quarterback, even though it appears to me he can play a number of positions.]
*
Al Schallau writes more about the 1957 Hawkeye football team that Time magazine called "The Team That Quit:"
"Ron,
"My good friend Randy Duncan is accurate in his memory of the 1957 Iowa vs. Michigan game at Ann Arbor; and he is brutally accurate about the magazine headline the next week that labeled the Hawkeyes as "The Team That Quit."
"Forest Evashevski and I discussed the 1957 Michigan game twice during our many phone conversations. Evy's reasoning for accepting a tie in the Michigan game went like this:
""When we started any football season, our number one objective was to win the Big Ten championship. I wanted to position the Iowa Hawkeyes to do that by beating Ohio State in our last conference game. I thought we could beat Ohio State, but we lost, 17-13. Bob White ran the ball down our throats in the fourth quarter. If we had won the Ohio State game, we would have won the Big Ten championship outright."
FACTUAL HISTORY CONCERNING 1957 BIG TEN FOOTBALL SEASON
"Iowa, Michigan, Michigan State, and Ohio State all had awesome teams in 1957 and all four expected to win the Big Ten championship. Evy figured that if Iowa finished the season with one tie and no losses, all the other teams would have at least one loss, and Iowa would be outright champion.
"In October, the other teams started suffering their one loss that Evy envisioned. On October 12, 1957, Michigan lost to Michigan State. On Oct. 19, 1957, Michigan State lost to Purdue. So that left only Iowa and Ohio State unbeaten in Big Ten games.
"Iowa played Michigan at Ann Arbor on Nov. 2, 1957. It was a muddy, rainy day. Michigan got ahead, 21-7, and it looked like Iowa would go home with one loss. Iowa scored two second half touchdowns and tied the game at 21-21. Yes, Evy decided to have his quarterback sit on the ball in the last two minutes because he did not want to risk a fumble on the wet field. Evy wanted to get out of Ann Arbor WITHOUT A LOSS. He was willing to accept a tie.
"Two weeks later, on Nov. 16, 1957, Iowa played Ohio State at Columbus. Iowa was ahead, 13-10, in the fourth quarter, until Bob White and the Buckeyes' offensive line took the ball down the field for the winning touchdown.
"I just got off the phone with Jim Gibbons, who was an all-American on the 1957 Hawkeye team. Among other things, he said:
"'In the Michigan game, we all knew that a tie didn't hurt us at all. We would win the Big Ten championship if we beat Ohio State. So on the trip back to Iowa City from Ann Arbor, we were perfectly happy to get out of the Michigan game with a tie.'
"So Evy's decision to accept a tie in the Michigan game was part of a profound strategy designed to win the Big Ten championship outright. Except for Bob White, his strategy would have worked.
"Best, AL SCHALLAU"
[RON MALY'S COMMENTS: All of this rewinding to a football game that was played 52 years ago, of course, is because of what happened in the final minute of regulation time in the Iowa-Ohio State game a week ago. Hawkeye coach Kirk Ferentz told quarterback James Vandenberg [No. 16 pictured at the left] and the Iowa offense to sit on the ball in the last 52 seconds so the teams would be tied, 24-24, heading into overtime. The Hawkeyes lost, 27-24, in a game that decided which Big Ten team would go to the Rose bowl. Schallau and plenty of other Hawkeye fans disagreed with Ferentz's decision. At the time, Iowa had Ohio State back on its heels, and it appeared a few well-placed passes in the last 52 seconds could have put the Hawkeyes into position for a winning field goal].














